2 Unusual Ways Your ‘Picky’ Habits Shape Your Love, By A Psychologist

Is your “pickiness” leading you closer to intimacy or keeping it out of reach? A new study reveals how these choices play out in modern dating.

getty

In the world of modern dating, it’s common for people to have their own “dating checklist.” This can include physical types, personality types, shared values, lifestyles and more. In creating it, they set certain standards for potential partners to meet.

Some people notice the slightest flaw, while others are more flexible, willing to explore connections even if someone doesn’t match every criterion.

Being selective or picky, is a normal part of dating. It can help you avoid mismatched relationships and find someone who truly fits your needs. This is generally a good thing. It helps you decide what you want, as well as what you’re not willing to accept in a partner.

Having clear standards gives you direction in dating.

While some people have set standards, others tend to be a little more easygoing in their approach. This gives them a chance to explore a variety of connections. They might be more open to getting to know a wide range of personalities, backgrounds or lifestyles, without sticking to a detailed list of things they want.

This doesn’t always mean that they don’t know what they want. It can just reflect a willingness to explore connections and discover compatibility in unexpected places. Many a time, this openness can even lead to surprising matches and experiences that those with more rigid standards might overlook.

While there’s no single “right” way to approach dating, it appears that being “picky” or choosy can be a double-edged sword.

In a June 2025 study published in Archives of Sexual Behavior, researchers set out to explore how different types of choosiness relate to sexual activity in single adults. They surveyed 340 single heterosexual adults in the U.S. who were all aged 18–40, with an equal split of 170 women and 170 men.

Based on the 2025 study, here’s how choosiness can impact your romantic life.

1. Knowing What You Want Can Boost Your Sex Life

Researchers explored romantic choosiness in two ways. The first was “stated choosiness.” This involved traits and qualities that participants identified as essential in a partner; their “non-negotiables.” Stated choosiness, essentially, reflects how clear and confident someone is about what they want in a relationship.

Of the 340 singles, the ones who reported higher levels of stated choosiness tended to engage in more partnered sexual activity. In fact, having clarity in your preferences can guide you toward compatible partners.

“People who know what they want may also have greater capacity to make informed decisions, which may mean that their navigation of sexual relationships is more successful,” the researchers affirm.

Researchers also found that people with higher stated choosiness tended to rate themselves as more attractive and reported greater confidence in their sexual desirability. This kind of clarity and confidence is also attractive to potential partners, leading to more opportunities for intimate connection.

When you strongly believe in your worth, you can make your standards work for you. You make more intentional choices knowing that you deserve the kind of romantic and sexual connection you want.

While this approach doesn’t always come naturally to everyone, it can be strengthened over time.

A good starting point is to engage in deeper self-reflection. Start by considering your past relationships. Try to understand what made those experiences positive or negative and what values, behaviors or personality traits feel essential to you in a relationship.

Remember not to focus only on external traits. It’s equally important to put an emphasis on how you want to feel in the relationship.

Pay close attention to moments when you feel genuinely at ease, excited or understood with someone. Then reflect on what contributed to those feelings. Conversely, remember to also pay attention to situations where you feel drained or disconnected. Notice what triggered those reactions.

As you focus on understanding what you want, don’t over-prioritize minor, more negotiable traits. This can limit opportunities to meet people who could be compatible in deeper, and perhaps even more meaningful ways.

The key is to strike a balance. Know what truly matters most to you while allowing room for flexibility and openness. This way, you can pursue connections that feel aligned you, while staying open to experiences that could pleasantly surprise you.

2. Being Too Picky Can Limit Opportunities In Love

The second type of choosiness the researchers studied was “revealed choosiness.” This reflects how selective people actually are when evaluating potential partners in practice, such as when rating dating profiles. Contrary to stated choosiness, which captures what people say they want, revealed choosiness measures real-world behavior and decision-making.

Paradoxically, the study found that participants who were highly selective in practice tended to have less partnered sexual activity. Those who consistently rated fewer potential partners positively were less likely to engage in sexual encounters.

People with lower confidence in their attractiveness also tended to be more critical when assessing others. Researchers suggest this could be a contributing factor that reduces their chances of forming sexual connections.

This also suggests that being overly critical or restrictive in practice may close off opportunities for intimacy, even when you desire it. While knowing what you want and being selective is valuable, confidence plays a key role in how that selectiveness plays out and the kind of impact it has.

With healthy self-esteem, you’re more likely to choose or dismiss partners based on genuine alignment with your desires, rather than fear or insecurity.

On the other hand, when selectiveness stems from low confidence or unyielding rigidity, it can easily tip over into being overly critical of others. This can cause you to shut down potential connections that could have grown into something meaningful, sexually or emotionally.

This is why it’s essential to reflect on what the true driving force behind your choices is.

In sexual relationships, this might mean noticing if you’re saying “no” to potential partners out of a lack of attraction or out of some kind of insecurity, for instance, out of the fear of being seen intimately.

In relationships, it could look like dismissing someone too quickly over minor traits or differences rather than exploring if the connection could feel fulfilling or passionate over time.

Having said that, staying open doesn’t mean lowering your standards. It means creating space for intimacy to unfold more naturally, rather than upholding rigid barriers to the very intimacy you seek.

Look At Dating As A Journey Of Self-Discovery

Dating, in many ways, can be a mirror of how you live. When you live in very rigid ways, life can feel limited. When you live without any structure at all, it can start to feel like your life is drifting away without direction. The key is learning to flow between clarity and openness.

Each connection, however lasting or short-lived, has the capacity to teach you something about what feels right to you and what doesn’t. You can view dating as an evolving process of discovery about yourself as much as it is about others.

Over time, the more you grow in confidence and ease, the more your relationships naturally begin to reflect that growth back to you.

Suppressed fears can shape the way you approach sex and relationships. Take the research-backed Sex Anxiety Inventory to find out if something’s holding you back.