Balancing Security, Privacy And UX

Rohan Pinto is CTO/Founder of 1Kosmos BlockID and a strong technologist with a strategic vision to lead technology-based growth initiatives.

In an era where digital interactions prevail, securing online identities has become a major concern, especially as traditional techniques like passwords and SMS-based two-factor authentication become more vulnerable to attacks.

This is why many companies are exploring AI-powered identity verification. While these tools can improve security and usability, they also pose concerns about privacy and user experience (UX). Let’s look at the potential and the challenges of these solutions.

AI In Biometric Authentication

Biometric authentication uses unique physiological or behavioral attributes to authenticate identity, and AI has considerably increased its accuracy and adaptability.

Modern facial recognition, for instance, uses convolutional neural networks (CNNs) to map facial traits into high-dimensional vectors. With this technology, AI can improve liveness detection by assessing micro-movements, texture and 3D depth to distinguish actual users from photographs or masks. For example, Apple’s Face ID employs infrared dot projection and on-device AI to prevent spoofing.

AI can also use spectral analysis and natural language processing (NLP) to examine vocal patterns, pitch and speech cadence. Advanced algorithms can detect synthetic voices or audio deepfakes by looking for unusual pauses or frequency distortions.

Finally, algorithms can interpret incomplete or low-quality fingerprints by extrapolating ridge patterns and reducing sensor noise. Smartphones like the Google Pixel use tensor processing units (TPUs) that are intended to offer more secure facial unlocking features.

While these solutions can eliminate the need for users to remember passwords and decrease the threat of fraud, their effectiveness is dependent on the quality and diversity of the training data.

AI In Fraud Detection And Deepfake Mitigation

As hackers use sophisticated tools such as generative adversarial networks (GANs) to build deepfakes and synthetic identities, AI plays a critical role in mitigating these dangers.

1. Anomaly Detection: Machine learning models use transaction patterns, IP addresses and device fingerprints to detect suspect activity. For example, Mastercard’s Decision Intelligence Pro platform employs AI to assess real-time payment risks.

2. Deepfake Identification: AI tools can also examine videos for abnormal blinking, uneven illumination or incorrect audio-video sync. Deepfakes can be detected by analyzing pixel-level abnormalities that are imperceptible to humans.

3. Behavioral Biometrics: AI creates personalized user profiles by tracking typing speed, mouse motions and swipe gestures. Companies use this technology for continuous authentication, which prevents account takeovers even when credentials are compromised.

While effective, these systems require frequent upgrades to keep up with changing hostile strategies.

Bias In AI Models

AI systems reflect the biases included in their training data.

Concerning facial recognition algorithms, in particular, studies—including a 2019 NIST analysis—have found that these solutions can perform worse when identifying women and people with darker skin tones, likely due to underrepresentation in the training data.

The potential consequences of biased training data could result in service denials or greater surveillance concerns for underrepresented groups, but there are several ways to mitigate this issue:

1. Curating Diverse And Representative Datasets: Data imbalance is a common source of AI bias. Mitigation entails gathering a variety of biometric samples, employing synthetic data such as GANs and updating datasets regularly, all while assuring consent and anonymity for ethical compliance.

2. Implementing Fairness Metrics And Algorithmic Adjustments: Models can be made more fair by incorporating metrics and auditing tools such as IBM’s AI Fairness 360. Techniques like threshold tuning and fairness-aware loss functions aid in balancing accuracy across groups.

3. Rigorous Third-Party Audits And Transparency: Independent assessments like NIST’s Face Recognition Vendor Test (FRVT), along with audits by academia or NGOs, can improve accountability. Publishing audit findings also fosters transparency and trust.

4. Inclusive Design And Stakeholder Collaboration: Cross-disciplinary collaboration among ethicists, users and policymakers can help to ensure that systems represent society’s ideals. On-device processing and federated learning are examples of privacy-focused strategies that help with secure, inclusive AI development.

5. Privacy-Preserving Techniques For Data Handling: On-device processing, federated learning and homomorphic encryption can enable secure, varied AI training without centralizing sensitive data.

In 2020, IBM, Amazon and Microsoft halted face recognition sales to law enforcement due to prejudice issues, underscoring the importance of ethical AI policies. To guarantee that AI supports inclusion rather than exclusion, it is necessary to build fair systems that use varied data, transparent processes and continual collaboration.

Privacy Implications And Regulatory Compliance

Biometric data is intrinsically sensitive. Unlike passwords, it cannot be reset once compromised. Because of these concerns, AI identity verification systems must also keep rigorous privacy guidelines in mind, including:

1. GDPR And CCPA: The GDPR (Article 9) defines biometrics as “special category data,” necessitating specific consent and purpose limitation. California’s CCPA allows consumers to opt out of allowing their biometric data to be sold.

2. Data Minimization: To limit exposure, AI models should process biometrics on-device, rather than on central servers.

3. Encryption And Anonymization: Techniques such as homomorphic encryption enable AI to examine encrypted data without decryption, helping to protect privacy.

Organizations must balance innovation with compliance, ensuring transparency in data usage to maintain user trust.

The Future: Passwordless Authentication And Behavioral Biometrics

Passwords are nearing obsolescence as AI-driven passwordless solutions gain traction. Here is a glimpse of what the password-less future might look like:

1. Phygital Convergence: Users will be authenticated by embedded biometric sensors in smart devices like wearables and automobiles.

2. Behavior Biometrics: AI will evaluate locomotion, eye movements and cognitive patterns to provide passive, continuous verification.

3. Decentralized Identity: Blockchain-based solutions, along with AI verification, could allow people to manage their digital identities without relying on centralized authority.

While AI-powered identity verification represents a paradigm leap in security, its success is dependent on comprehensively addressing bias, privacy and UX issues. User acceptance of pervasive biometric monitoring and guaranteeing platform interoperability will also be crucial challenges to overcome.

Stakeholders must work together to develop ethical principles, invest in inclusive technologies and prioritize user-centered design. As deepfakes and cyberthreats become more sophisticated, the next frontier of digital trust will be defined by the balance between absolute security and fundamental privacy rights.

The future can be password-free, but only if we create it wisely.

Forbes Technology Council is an invitation-only community for world-class CIOs, CTOs and technology executives. Do I qualify?