2 Ways To Break Out of A Couple ‘Conflict Loop,’ By A Psychologist

Are you running in circles with the same fights? Here’s why your arguments never really end, keeping you stuck in the same “conflict loop.”

getty

Conflicts and disagreements are a natural part of any healthy relationship. When handled well, they can even help bring people closer. When you disagree, you’re showing your true thoughts and boundaries instead of pretending everything is fine.

If both people listen and work through these moments with respect, it can benefit the relationship in many ways, such as creating an increasing understanding between partners, and helping them learn what matters to the other person and why.

In short, a healthy conflict serves as a reminder that the relationship can survive tough moments and even deepen because of them.

However, it can get unhealthy when you keep having the same kind of fight. You might notice that no matter what sparks the fight, be it dishes, tone of voice or texting habits, it somehow always circles back to the same emotional pain points and the real issue never ends up getting addressed.

This is a “conflict loop,” a pattern where you’re just replaying old hurts and unfinished conversations.

You might feel pulled into protecting your ego, wanting to be right, proving a point or “winning” the argument. While in the moment that can feel satisfying, it often comes at the cost of truly hearing each other. The real goal of the conversation shifts from understanding to defending.

This cycle, over time, erodes trust and a sense of safety in the relationship. The relationship might start to feel less safe because both people begin to anticipate the next fight before it even happens.

To come out of this loop, it’s important to recognize its existence in the first place. Here are two signs that your relationship is stuck in a conflict loop.

1. You’re Fighting About Surface Issues

Often in a relationship, without even realizing it, one partner or even both can start feeling unseen, unheard or unappreciated.

Ideally, the healthy way is to address it early on through open communication. But it’s possible you don’t recognize these feelings for what they are or aren’t able to express them in the moment. As a result, such emotions can get pushed aside, which can build resentment.

This happens because deeper needs often feel too vulnerable to name in the moment, and so, they stay hidden. When they’re not addressed, every new argument becomes another way of expressing the same old hurt.

This can resurface later as small irritations, passive-aggressive remarks or arguments over things that don’t seem like the “real” problem.

On the surface, it may look like you’re fighting about a specific behavior. But underneath, it could be about something deeper, maybe a need for respect, closeness or emotional safety that isn’t being met.

In a 2023 study, researchers tested a psychological theory called “control-mastery theory.” It suggests that couples with chronic conflict are often part of a “relational vicious circle” where each partner is unconsciously “testing” deep and harmful beliefs about themselves, which are also called pathogenic beliefs. The other partner’s reaction ends up confirming those beliefs instead of disproving them.

Researchers wanted to see whether feelings of interpersonal guilt (guilt about hurting, disappointing or burdening the other person) are more present during couple conflicts.

They worked with 11 couples in therapy, with four experienced therapists using session transcripts (word-for-word records) from the couples’ psychotherapy. Nine trained judges read these transcripts and rated them, comparing conflictual and non-conflictual segments of conversations.

Researchers found that in conflicts, both partners showed more “testing” behavior, essentially trying to see if their partner would disprove their deep fears (such as “I’m unlovable” and “I’m not important”) but instead getting responses that confirmed those fears. Conflictual moments also carried more interpersonal guilt than calmer moments.

For instance, if you have an underlying belief that you are not worth prioritizing, you might test your partner by noticing if they listen or show care during a disagreement. But if the fight stays focused on surface issues instead of addressing the deeper need, that test fails and it leaves you feeling exactly what you feared: that you do not matter.

This means that conflict can reinforce the original wound instead of repairing it. The key to dealing with this is to move past the surface issue and get curious about the real need underneath; both yours and your partner’s.

Instead of aiming to “win” the argument, try to notice what belief might be getting tested in that moment. Start by asking yourself what you’re afraid this conflict might “confirm” about you, and move your focus to understanding what your partner is afraid it’ll confirm about them.

When you slowly learn how to respond instead of reacting to the current issue and face fear instead of giving into frustration, you give each other a chance to disconfirm those old beliefs.

2. Every Fight Brings Up Past Issues And Hurt

You can tell you’re in a conflict loop when arguments start carrying more weight than the situation deserves. A small disagreement, let’s say, about being late, forgetting a chore or a slightly sharp tone, could snowball into airing every past disappointment.

This often sounds like “You always do this,” or “This is just like last time” or “And remember when you…”

What starts as one conversation can slowly turn into a replay of your entire conflict history.

This is also called “kitchen sinking,” where instead of dealing with the present conflict, you pile all your unresolved hurt into it. This makes the issue at hand feel unfixable, because you’re not just solving today’s problem but you’re also trying to resolve a backlog of emotional debt in one go.

Previous studies have shown that recalling positive shared memories (like a great trip or a sweet moment) can make couples feel closer and warmer toward each other.

However, in a 2024 study published in the Journal of Social and Personal Psychology, researchers wanted to flip the lens. They wanted to learn what happens when couples recall negative memories instead, and whether remembering relationship conflicts decrease feelings of intimacy in the present.

Researchers found that recalling positive memories increased closeness, while negative memories reduced warmth.

Feelings of closeness also declined when the conflict felt personally significant and when participants had used avoidance or self-distraction to cope at the time. This means that the emotional cost is even higher if the conflict was never well-processed in the first place.

This is exactly why kitchen-sinking feels so damaging in the middle of a fight, because you’re not only digging up the past but also reactivating its emotional impact. It can make you feel less connected in the moment, probably when you most need connection.

When an old hurt comes up during a disagreement, pause and ask yourself if it’s about today or if you’re trying to use something from the past to prove that you’re right. Start noticing the pattern and understand if you often bring up the past to strengthen your argument.

If so, try shifting the focus. Maybe slow down and ask yourself, “What is the actual issue here, right now?”

By separating the past from the present and aiming to understand the core problem, you give the current conflict a fair chance to be resolved.

Start by learning to respond consciously to the current argument and eventually, in a calmer moment when you can both reflect mindfully, try focusing on the bigger issue at play.

Conflict loops can only break when you start dealing with what’s actually happening or what’s been hidden for long.

Both partners need to learn to strike a balance between knowing when to stop digging into the past and being able to spot the patterns that keep resurfacing. The goal isn’t to ignore history. You just need to recognize which old issues are worth addressing later and which are just being pulled in to win today’s argument.

In the moment, aim to understand the real need or fear underneath, for both you and your partner. This way, the conversation can move toward repair instead of repetition.

When resolution becomes the focus, even hard conversations can bring you closer instead of pushing you apart.

Wondering if you and your partner resolve conflict productively or destructively? Take the science-backed Ineffective Arguing Inventory to find out.