JONATHAN TURLEY: British police arrest comedy writer for transgender activist criticism

In the anti-free speech community, the most intolerable form of speech often seems to be humor. For thousands of years, satire and parody have proven to be the most penetrating —and at times, irritating —forms of political speech. Even with absolute rulers, court jesters were often the few figures who could challenge a king. As Shakespeare wrote in “King Lear,” “jesters do oft prove prophets.”

In the case of comedian Graham Linehan, he has unwittingly become a prophet for the death of not just free speech but also humor in the United Kingdom. The co-creator of the U.K. sitcom “Father Ted” was arrested at London Heathrow Airport, allegedly over several social media posts criticizing transgender activists. The posts were not jokes, but political commentary.

Linehan ended up in the hospital after he said that he was met by five armed officers, who told him he was being arrested over three posts on X. In an essay published on his Substack about his arrest and hospitalization, Linehan shared that he felt the need as a comedic writer to emphasize, “no, I promise you, I am not making this up.”

UK COMEDY WRITER GRAHAM LINEHAN ARRESTED OVER SOCIAL MEDIA POSTS CRITICIZING TRANS ACTIVISTS

He said that officers interrogated him over an X post in which he wrote, “If a trans-identified male is in a female-only space, he is committing a violent, abusive act.” He added that people would be compelled to make a scene, call the police, or even “punch” the offender.

London’s Metropolitan Police confirmed that it had arrested a man “in connection with posts on X.” Linehan said that he was told that there would be only one bail condition: “I am not to go on Twitter. That’s it. No threats, no speeches about the seriousness of my crimes – just a legal gag order designed to shut me up while I’m in the U.K.”

Irish comedy writer Graham Linehan leaves Westminster Magistrates Court on September 4, 2025, in London, England. Linehan appeared in court charged with harassment without violence and criminal damage in connection with an incident that took place in 2024. Linehan, who is known for co-creating TV sitcoms such as “Father Ted” and “The IT Crowd,” has also been outspoken against the trans rights movement. Linehan was arrested on September 1 on suspicion of inciting violence over anti-trans social media posts he made earlier this year.  (Alishia Abodunde/Getty Images)

For those who live in Great Britain or other European countries, this is hardly surprising. The government has steadily increased its criminalization and regulation of speech, including religious and political speech, under such laws as the Communications Act of 2003 and the Online Safety Act of 2023.

British citizens are not alone. For years, free speech has been no laughing matter in Europe and other parts of the world. Comedians have been charged in countries ranging from France to Germany to Brazil to Turkey to Canada for insulting jokes.

In my book, “The Indispensable Right: Free Speech in an Age of Rage,” I discuss how free speech is in free fall in Europe, where the European Union is pushing for global censorship of social media, including American companies. The most triggering sound for many people today is the sound of laughter from those who hold opposing views.

‘MONTY PYTHON’ COMEDIAN SAYS TRUMP EMBOLDENED PEOPLE TO LAUGH AGAIN AFTER WOKE ACTIVISTS RUINED COMEDY

In Scotland, comedians opposed a draconian law that threatened to criminalize a wide swath of jokes. It would allow the arrest of anyone deemed guilty of “stirring up hatred” against a group of persons and even allow for arrests for possessing inflammatory material with a view to communicating the material.

The pathological lack of humor is shared by many in this country. In Hawaii, comedians and others opposed a law that criminalizes “recklessly” distributing “materially deceptive media.” At universities, the dominant anti-free speech culture is raising not just a generation of speech phobics but humorless speech phobics.

“Father Ted” co-creator Graham Linehan speaks to the media outside Westminster Magistrates’ Court, London on May 12. The Irish comedy writer, 56, pleaded not guilty to harassing a transgender woman and damaging her phone.  (Lucy North/PA Images via Getty Images)

Past polls showed that as many as six out of ten students viewed “offensive jokes” to be “hate speech.” Comedians have been routinely canceled on college campuses and many will no longer perform at colleges and universities due to the intolerance.

CLICK HERE FOR MORE FOX NEWS OPINION

The public still values edgy comedy, as shown by the success of Fox News’ “Gutfeld!” which has surpassed traditional network late-night shows in the ratings.

It turns out the public does not want humor that runs only from the left to the far-left. The latest example is “The Late Show with Stephen Colbert,” which has not only lost viewers but also a reported $50 million a year with its exclusive left-only humor shtick.

Ironically, the country that brought us Monty Python is now mainstreaming George Orwell. In Great Britain, the range of acceptable humor is left to the government to decide. 

It is a standard that seems to follow the dubious lead of Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart on recognizing pornography in Jacobellis v. Ohio, 378 U.S. 184 (1964): “I shall not today attempt further to define the kinds of material I understand to be embraced within that shorthand description; and perhaps I could never succeed in intelligibly doing so. But I know it when I see it.”

Comedians like Linehan are left with permissible humor dictated by the anemic comedic stylings of the far left or that of the Metropolitan Police.

CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP

Empowered by such censorship laws, activists often seem to spend more time trying to silence others in Europe than speaking for themselves. Individuals and groups will often file criminal complaints against those with opposing views. That has included an unrelenting campaign against author J.K. Rowling and others who have opposed transgender policies as destroying feminist gains in sports and other fields.

Author J.K. Rowling arrives at the “Fantastic Beasts: The Secret of Dumbledore” world premiere at The Royal Festival Hall on March 29, 2022, in London, England.  (Photo by Stuart C. Wilson/Getty Images)

Of course, censorship itself is now a form of release for the humor-challenged and viewpoint-intolerant. While most sensible people look at Linehan’s arrest with horror, it was a thrill, even fun, for those who use these laws. They show little fear that these laws might one day be turned against them. After all, as Will Rogers explained, “everything is funny, as long as it’s happening to somebody else.”

CLICK HERE TO READ MORE FROM JONATHAN TURLEY