The Marketing Metrics That Will Matter Most In The Age Of AI Agents

AI agents are set to reshape marketing by making many traditional metrics like clicks, impressions and bounce rates less relevant.

Adobe Stock

Since the arrival of the internet and online marketing, measuring and analyzing certain metrics has been essential for those wanting to attract audiences and sell online.

Figures like click-through rates, page impressions, and conversions have traditionally provided marketers with the insight needed to make decisions about how, when, and where to present their products and services to us.

Those days, however, could be coming to an end. The arrival of agents—AI assistants that can carry out complex tasks, including making buying decisions, with minimal human interaction—is set to turn everything we know about digital marketing on its head.

Agents are already capable of making travel arrangements and shopping online on our behalf. And because they don’t buy and browse the same way we humans do, many of the methods and metrics used by marketers to predict behavior and judge intent are likely to become much less useful.

So, if the usefulness of traditional metrics is fading, what should businesses be looking to measure and analyze in order to increase sales and customer loyalty in the agentic age?

How Agents Are Changing The Game

Marketers are used to technological leaps forcing them to rethink strategies from the ground up. The arrival of online retail, search engine marketing and the mobile internet all brought massive change to the way we search, shop and buy.

AI agents represent the next great paradigm shift. They are less likely to be influenced by what a customer’s favorite content creator is showing off on Instagram or clever lifestyle marketing campaigns.

Click rates—a metric showing the number of times a page or product listing is visited by a potential buyer—are less valuable as indicators in the “zero click” age, where many purchases might be completed without a user ever visiting a site.

Likewise, Impressions, traditionally another key metric showing how often a listing is seen, could count for less when agents are simply parsing content to extract data, and won’t be influenced to look closer by clever copywriting or eye-catching design.

And Bounce rates give marketers insight into when they are simply showing information that isn’t relevant to an audience, causing them to stop browsing a site, or technical issues like slow-loading pages. AI agents don’t “bounce” or get bored; they will simply ingest everything they’re given and move on in accordance with their algorithms and training.

Just as earlier paradigm shifts required digital marketing playbooks to be rewritten from scratch, these metrics and perhaps other old favorites, such as those indicating the amount of time spent by visitors on a particular page, or even social engagement (likes and shares), will be less meaningful. So, what should marketers be looking for instead?

What Metrics Matter Now?

With the importance of clicks, impressions, bounce rates and other familiar metrics slipping, focus should instead shift to those that give insights into how machines retrieve data, evaluate it, and take action.

Among the most important will be indicators that reflect data quality and structure. Agents are likely to give preference to information they find easy to parse and interpret. This means that measures such as how well-defined your schema is, and how accessible information is through APIs, could be critical.

Other indicators to look out for are those that signal authority or trustworthiness. Verified customer reviews, citations by notable sources and compliance with recognized standards and certifications could become increasingly important factors here.

And reliability is likely to be another factor in agentic decision-making. This means metrics that suggest a business has many repeat purchasers, values long-term customer relationships and has low levels of customer churn could be useful.

Of course, it will also be essential to be able to tell how many buying decisions are being made by machines, so metrics that let us quantify human versus agent-initiated sales are also essential.

Another important concept to measure and understand is likely to be Query Match— an indicator of how closely your content matches questions that users are asking. If your product information pages and listings provide direct answers to common questions, agents could consider them more relevant.

The common thread running through all of these is that they are metrics that reflect machine behavior rather than human behavior. Understanding the difference and its importance will be key to navigating the next wave of change.

The Future Of Marketing To Agents

Of course, these changes aren’t going to take place overnight. It’s likely to be some time before everyone is ready to let machines make their buying decisions. But studies suggest it’s happening, with 24 percent of us (and 32 percent of Gen-Z) already agreeable to the idea.

It’s also important to note that tools for measuring and reporting some of the metrics covered here are not as mature or precise as those for tracking more commonly used metrics like click-through rates and page impressions. This is likely to change, however, as more marketers become aware of their significance.

One mistake that many companies will likely make is treating agents as simply another marketing channel, alongside search engine marketing, organic social media, and paid-for display advertising. Agents aren’t likely to simply sit alongside these as another option for connecting with customers; instead, they’ll fundamentally rewire the way each of them works.

The key takeaway? Don’t wait for this to happen, and take action now. History shows that innovators who anticipated and acted swiftly in the face of previous tech-driven paradigm shifts were those who reaped the rewards.

Acting now to ensure your marketing content, product listings, customer feedback and reviews are structured, reliable and accessible, your credibility and authority are clearly signposted, and your systems can distinguish between human and agent-driven interactions, is likely to set you up for success.